The largest independent, non-commercial, consumer-oriented resource on the Internet for owners, collectors and enthusiasts of fine wristwatches. Online since 1998.
Informational Websites ChronoMaddox -- the legacy of Chuck Maddox OnTheDash -- vintage Heuer website Zowie -- Omega information
Discussion Forums ChronoMaddox Forum Heuer Forum Omega Forum
Counterfeit Watchers ChronoTools Forum ChronoTrader Forum
Vintage Heuer Discussion Forum
The place for discussing 1930-1985 Heuer wristwatches, chronographs and dash-mounted timepieces. Online since May 2003.
OnTheDash Home What's New! Price Guide Chronographs Dash Mounted Collection
Re: Zodiac
In Response To: Zodiac *PIC* ()

: Here is my Zodiac that I believe has the same case as the later
: Carrera, Its chrome plated though unlike the Heuer in stainless.
: I have not seen any other Zodiac, Tradition or other poor mans
: with this style case. So certainly a cheaper model due to
: materials used. As to who assembled it, I can not say, only that
: they went to a lot of trouble to emulate the Carrera. Yes Jeff I
: agree the community has handled this members assault very well.
: I my self was some what shocked at the original posting and
: really wondered what was his purpose. I'm still puzzled !
: Perhaps he could explain his some what aggressive attitude.

Hi!
Let me add my 5 cents to this discussion. There lots of watches using exactly this same chromiun plated case. One of them I can show, here. This Sears Tradition is equiped with a nice column wheel Valjoux 92 chronograph movement.

There were even Heuer branded Carreras and pre-Carreras on these "economy" cases.
I do believe that the Zodiacs, Traditions, Clebars and and a full hand of other brands have marketed watches fully assembled by Heuer under an OEM agreement, or something like that. For logical reasons, indeed. Knowing any kind of industrial process, you'd realize that it was nearly impossible to make it in any other way. It is very very unlikely that a brand, like Zodiac or any other, could manage to convince an entire set of different suppliers to sell them exactly the same components, with the same painting/color schema, using an arrangement designed by Heuer without Heuer's consent. Moreover, it would hardly show economically viable. They would need to train people, set assembly lines, acquire tools, etc for very limited production volumes.
As you said, it would be a lot of trouble trying to do like that.
I recently found this Eska. I've never heard of any association between Heuer and Eska, and have never seen any "brother" to this watch.

Nevertheless, I can't believe that such a small brand like Eska could manage to acquire this set of components not involving an agreement with Heuer. Industry doesn't work like that - not the Swiss watchmaking industry. Not today, not ever...

Messages In This Thread

Just finished reading the article "Poor Man's Heuers"
Zodiac *PIC*
Re: Zodiac
Re: Zodiac
Here is physical proof
Re: Here is physical proof
Forum Not Dragged Down by Our Visitor
Speaking of the world *PIC*
Re: Just finished reading the article "Poor Man's Heuers"
Re: Just finished reading the article "Poor Man's Heuers"
Re: Just finished reading the article "Poor Man's Heuers"
Practical proof...
Further Proof in Jack Heuer's Autobiography
Physical or Written Proof re "Poor Man's" Heuers
Re: Physical or Written Proof re "Poor Man's" Heuers
Doubtful; These were Private Conversations
Re: Doubtful; These were Private Conversations
You Are Wrong
This is getting out of hand... Why do I see Heuer cases?
Re: You Are Wrong
Re: You Are Wrong
Re: You Are Wrong
Happy to Answer Your Questions
Jeff you need proof? I have one...
Re: Happy to Answer Your Questions
Re: Advice to dmh
It is perfectly legal to be wrong...
Re: You Are Wrong
Re: Doubtful; These were Private Conversations
Re: Doubtful; These were Private Conversations
Re: Doubtful; These were Private Conversations
Heuer Carrera, Overprinted to Become "Zodiac"
Re: Heuer Carrera, Overprinted to Become "Zodiac"
This isn't news for anyone who knows how the Swiss...
Re: This isn't news for anyone who knows how the Swiss...
Let Me Add One Point -- Catalogs and Chronographs
Re: Let Me Add One Point -- Catalogs and Chronographs
I Was Thinking More About the 1960s; No Bashing from Me
Re: I Was Thinking More About the 1960s; No Bashing from Me
and do not forget the ones made with Bulova on the dial
Re: and do not forget the ones made with Bulova on the dial
Current Position
Chronocentric and zOwie site design and contents (c) Copyright 1998-2005, Derek Ziglar; Copyright 2005-2008, Jeffrey M. Stein. All rights reserved. Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the terms of use. CONTACT | TERMS OF USE | TRANSLATE